Allstate Fire & Casualty Insurance Violates Vermont Law

When it comes to common market conduct criticisms for insurers, the claims, underwriting, and sales processes are top spots of contention. Compliance penalties are serious and can include cease and desist orders, consent orders, fines, license suspensions, or the loss of the company’s certificate of authority. Allstate Fire & Casualty Insurance (Allstate) recently found themselves in hot water in the state of Vermont for their claims processes, resulting in $225,000 in fines plus restitution to any third-party claimant whose claim was initially denied due to the negligence.

Lou Penn

Allstate Stipulation & Consent Order 

The Vermont Department of Financial Regulation examined the claims settlement practices of Allstate in claims handling involving comparative negligence in order to determine whether they were handled in accordance with Vermont law. The department identified violations in 8. V.S.A., which constitutes unfair or deceptive acts or practices in the business of insurance in violation of 8 V.S.A. 4723. The department identified the following violations:

    • Failure to adopt and implement reasonable standards for the prompt investigation of claims arising under insurance policies
    • Refusal to pay claims without conducting a reasonable investigation based upon all available information.

The department concluded that Allstate violated Regulation I-79-2 §7 by failing to provide claimants with appropriate reasons for denial, including a reference to the applicable policy provision, condition, or exclusion. The department also concluded that Allstate violated 8 V.S.A. § 4793(a), which prohibits any person from acting as an insurance adjuster unless duly licensed. The department identified numerous claims that were settled without having been reviewed by a Vermont licensed adjuster.

Read the full listing from Market Conduct Auditor® on Allstate’s stipulations and consent order.

Stay in Compliance 

There are many possible reasons for Allstate’s non-compliance. Internal inefficiencies, lack of proper controls, insufficient analysis or testing of processes, and/or unfamiliarity with regulatory requirements are often the cause of the violations resulting in penalties. 

Using Market Conduct Auditor® and the expert insight of a third-party consultant like Lou Penn & Associates can help you avoid costly mistakes like this one. Contact us today for a demo of Market Conduct Auditor®.